10 Cover Letter Mistakes That Kill Your Chances in 2025 (Avoid These)
What Are the Most Common Cover Letter Mistakes?
After analyzing hundreds of cover letters and rejection patterns, we’ve identified the exact mistakes that qualified candidates make. Some of these might surprise you.
The worst part? Most of these mistakes take just 30 seconds to fix.
1. Using the Wrong Company Name
The Mistake: Copy-pasting cover letters and forgetting to update company names.
Why It Kills Your Chances: It signals carelessness and lack of attention to detail. Hiring managers immediately know you’re mass-applying without genuine interest.
The Fix: Create a template but always double-check:
- Company name (every mention)
- Job title
- Hiring manager’s name
- Platform where you found the job
Pro Tip: Set up a checklist for every application. This mistake is more common than you think - even experienced professionals do this.
2. Writing “To Whom It May Concern”
The Mistake: Using generic greetings when you could find a specific name.
Why It Kills Your Chances: It shows laziness. Hiring managers think: “If they can’t spend 5 minutes researching our team, how will they handle actual work?”
The Fix: Spend 5 minutes on LinkedIn or the company website. Look for:
- The hiring manager’s name in the job posting
- The department head you’d report to
- HR personnel who post about openings
If You Can’t Find a Name: Use “Dear Hiring Team” or “Dear [Department] Team” instead.
3. Rehashing Your Resume Word-for-Word
The Mistake: Simply repeating everything already listed on your resume.
Why It Kills Your Chances: Hiring managers want NEW information that expands on your resume, not a duplicate.
The Fix: Use the cover letter to:
- Provide context behind your achievements
- Explain career transitions or gaps
- Share specific examples not on your resume
- Show your personality and communication style
Example: ❌ “I managed social media accounts” ✅ “I transformed our social media strategy by implementing user-generated content campaigns, resulting in 400% higher engagement and 50 new leads per month”
4. Ignoring the ATS
The Mistake: Using fancy formatting, headers, or keywords that automated screening systems can’t parse.
Why It Kills Your Chances: Most applications are automatically filtered before reaching human reviewers. Complex formatting can cause your application to be misread or rejected.
The Fix:
- Use standard fonts (Arial, Calibri, Times New Roman)
- Avoid headers, footers, tables, or text boxes
- Save as .docx or .pdf as requested
- Use exact keywords from the job description
5. Focusing Only on Yourself
The Mistake: Writing entire paragraphs about what you want from the role.
Why It Kills Your Chances: Hiring managers want to know what you’ll do for THEM, not what they can do for you.
The Fix: Flip your perspective: ❌ “I am looking for a role where I can grow my leadership skills” ✅ “I’m excited to apply my leadership experience to mentor your junior developers and drive your team’s sprint velocity goals”
6. Being Too Modest
The Mistake: Downplaying achievements or using weak language like “I think” or “I believe I might be able to…”
Why It Kills Your Chances: If you don’t believe in your abilities, why should they?
The Fix: State your achievements confidently: ❌ “I think I helped improve our conversion rates” ✅ “I increased conversion rates by 34% through A/B testing and user experience optimization”
7. Using Generic Language
The Mistake: Filling your letter with buzzwords and clichés that could apply to anyone.
Why It Kills Your Chances: Generic language makes you forgettable. You blend in with hundreds of other applications.
The Fix: Replace generic phrases with specific examples: ❌ “I’m a team player with excellent communication skills” ✅ “I facilitated weekly cross-team standups that reduced project conflicts by 60% and improved delivery times”
8. Ignoring Company Research
The Mistake: Not mentioning anything specific about the company, their products, or recent news.
Why It Kills Your Chances: It signals you’re mass-applying and don’t really care about THIS specific opportunity.
The Fix: Spend 10 minutes researching:
- Recent company news or product launches
- Their mission and values
- Industry challenges they’re facing
- Their tech stack or methodologies
Then weave this into your letter naturally.
9. Avoiding Skill Gaps
The Mistake: Pretending you have every qualification or ignoring obvious gaps.
Why It Kills Your Chances: Hiring managers spot resume lies instantly. Ignoring gaps makes you seem unaware or dishonest.
The Fix: Address gaps proactively: “While I don’t have direct experience with Kubernetes, my extensive Docker background provides a strong foundation. I’ve already started the CKA certification course and am committed to becoming proficient within 60 days.”
For a complete strategy on handling skill gaps, read our detailed guide on addressing missing qualifications.
10. Weak or Missing Call-to-Action
The Mistake: Ending with “I look forward to hearing from you” or “Thank you for your consideration.”
Why It Kills Your Chances: Passive endings don’t create urgency or excitement.
The Fix: End with confidence and specificity: ❌ “I hope to hear from you soon” ✅ “I’m excited to discuss how my experience scaling React applications can help TechFlow achieve its Q2 performance goals. I’ll follow up next week to ensure you received my application.”
The Hidden Mistake: Wrong File Name
Bonus Mistake: Saving your cover letter as “Cover Letter.pdf” or “Document1.pdf”
Why It Matters: Hiring managers review dozens of applications. Clear file names help them stay organized.
The Fix: Use this format: “FirstName_LastName_CoverLetter_CompanyName.pdf”
Quick Self-Audit Checklist
Before sending any cover letter, verify these critical elements:
Content Accuracy:
- ✅ Company name is correct everywhere it appears
- ✅ Job title matches posting exactly
- ✅ Hiring manager’s name is spelled correctly
Content Quality:
- ✅ Specific achievements with numbers included
- ✅ Keywords from job description naturally integrated
- ✅ Company research demonstrated in 1-2 sentences
- ✅ Skill gaps addressed honestly and constructively
Professional Presentation:
- ✅ Strong, specific call-to-action (not “I hope to hear from you”)
- ✅ Professional file name: FirstName_LastName_CoverLetter_CompanyName.pdf
- ✅ Proofread for typos and grammar errors
- ✅ Saved in requested format (.pdf or .docx as specified)
The Recovery Plan
If you’ve been making these mistakes, here’s how to improve:
- Audit your recent applications - Which mistakes were you making?
- Create a new template that addresses these issues
- Research each company before applying
- Track your results - Are you getting more responses?
Remember: Your goal isn’t to be perfect. Your goal is to be better than the other 200+ applications they’re reviewing.
Master Your Job Search
📈 Take Your Applications to the Next Level:
- How to Write a Cover Letter That Gets You Hired in 2025 - Complete guide
- How to Address Skill Gaps in Job Applications - Turn gaps into strengths
- From 100+ Job Rejections to Building an AI Solution - Why most rejections happen
Tired of making these mistakes? jobLetterAI automatically checks for common errors and optimizes your cover letters for both ATS systems and hiring managers. Get early access and never worry about these mistakes again.
Get Weekly Job Search Tips
Join 200+ professionals getting insider job search strategies and early access to jobLetterAI